Banks' inequity in home-equity loans

Picture this nightmare financial scenario: You’ve taken out a $150,000 home-equity credit line to remodel your house. You’ve already pulled out thousands to pay contractors and owe thousands more, when suddenly you get a curt letter from the bank.

“Effective yesterday,” it says, “we’ve shut down access to your credit line. Although we haven’t physically appraised your property, an automated valuation indicates that it is now worth significantly less than it was when we approved your application. If you wish to hire an appraiser, chosen by us but at your own expense, you can appeal our decision.”

You’re in shock. You can’t pay bills for work you’ve contracted, and you can’t touch the money you confidently thought you had. Plus, you know that housing prices in your area have been relatively stable since you took out the credit line. How could a bank effectively devalue your real estate using nothing more than a computer program?

Welcome to the world of what class-action lawyers estimate to be massive numbers of homeowners — 1 million customers at one national bank alone — who had their credit lines reduced, frozen or canceled without appraisals during 2009 in the tense months following the near-collapse of the capital marketplace.

Now a federal district court in Chicago has given the green light to clients of JPMorgan Chase to proceed with a consolidated lawsuit alleging that their equity lines were yanked or reduced illegally, costing them billions of dollars in lost borrowing power. Judge Rebecca Pallmeyer rejected the bank’s motion to dismiss the case, clearing the way for a possible giant class action.

The litigation pulls together eight suits seeking class certification filed by homeowners in Arizona, California, Illinois, Minnesota, Ohio and Texas. It is considered a bellwether test of the rights homeowners have under the Truth in Lending Act and state consumer protection statutes when they take out equity lines of credit.

It also shines light on the controversial computerized tools many lenders use to make quick, inexpensive assessments of property values in lieu of more costly professional appraisals. Suits on similar grounds are pending against other major lenders, including Wells Fargo, GMAC Mortgage and Citibank, lawyers said.

The plaintiffs’ attorneys are challenging JPMorgan Chase’s legal right to rescind or limit credit lines without adequate documentation that property values have dropped “significantly,” required by the truth-in-lending law. They also are mounting a side attack against automated valuation models (AVMs) that they say are frequently inaccurate and unreliable.

Ohio Home Equity Loans - News


Banks' inequity in home-equity loans

Picture this nightmare financial scenario: You've taken out a $150000 home-equity credit line to remodel your house. You've already pulled out thousands to pay contractors and owe thousands more, when suddenly you get a curt



$168 million securities fraud settlement proposed
$168 million securities fraud settlement proposed

The suit alleges National City misrepresented the quality of its mortgages and home equity loans and the severity of its losses. The settlement is expected to go before US District Judge Solomon Oliver Jr. in the Northern District of Ohio for



Consumers get scant relief from debt deal
Consumers get scant relief from debt deal

The collective impact of higher loan costs goes beyond the individual loans, as McBride noted. "The more money that individuals are devoting to interest charges on credit cards and home equity loans and student loans, the less available to be spent



Fair sues Shelbyville bank over sale of Durham Duesenberg
Fair sues Shelbyville bank over sale of Durham Duesenberg

The trustee alleges Fair is entitled to the $316139, since the car had not served as collateral on the home equity loan. He also is objecting to the $197731 the bank is claiming in fees and expenses, calling them “grossly excessive and unreasonable.



Fifth Third Bancorp Announces Second Quarter 2011 Net Income to Common ...

Average auto loans increased 1 percent sequentially and 10 percent year-over-year as continued strong loan origination volumes more than offset pay-downs. This growth was partially offset by lower home equity loan balances, which declined 2 percent




Home Equity Loan Special - Ohio Catholic Federal Credit Union

- Low minimum payments 

 

 

*APR is Annual Percentage Rate. The Annual Percentage Rate is the advertised rate and can vary based on creditworthiness.  Promotional rates are available August 4, 2011, to August 9, 2011.  Loan term up to 10 years.  Minimum $20,000 loan amount required and $200,000 maximum loan amount available.  Loan must close by August 20, 2011.  Home Equity Loans or Second Mortgage Loans currently financed through Ohio Catholic cannot be refinanced with this offer.  This offer is available only on owner occupied homes.  Property insurance required.  Flood insurance may be required.  If you respond to this offer but do not meet the criteria for the loan at the time of your application or if you do not provide the required collateral, we may not be able to extend credit to you.  Ohio Catholic Federal Credit Union may discontinue or change program without notice. Payment examples: loan amount of $50,000 at 3.99% (4.01% APR with $50 loan documentation fee) for 120 months would have a monthly payment of $506.49.


Twitter

Jeanetta Sanfratello Ohio Home Equity Loans – Interest Only Home Equity Loans: Layoffs, small business failures, and other economic p...


Onie Guilmette Ohio Home Equity Loans – Interest Only Home Equity Loans: Layoffs, small business failures, and other economic p...


Ohio Home Equity Loans - Bookshelf

Modern real estate practice in Ohio

Modern real estate practice in Ohio

Home equity loans are a source of funds for homeowners to use Loans ^or a variety of ... A home equity loan can be taken out as a fixed loan amount or as an ...

American banker, index

American banker, index

Unit Raises Target; by Marc Hochstein; [News] First Horizon Home Loan Corp; .... by Jody Shenn; [News] DeepGreen Bank-Seven Hills OH; Home equity loans; ...

Kiplinger's Personal Finance

Kiplinger's Personal Finance

YOUR HOME Paying off a home-equity loan • Bedrooms designed for kids Blending ... says David Johnston, a Wooster, Ohio, consultant on heating and venting. ...

BNA's banking report

BNA's banking report

The "Home Equity Loan Consumer Protection Act" would require detailed, ... Chalmers Wylie (R-Ohio) and Rep. John Hiler (R- Ind), ranking Republican on the ...

ABA Journal

ABA Journal

Not available on home equity loans or lines of credit. ... 212/588-9200 Southeast Blynn, Richards & Associates 770/993-1623 Michigan/Ohio Charla Breton ...

Helpful News Directory


Ohio Home Equity Loan or Line of Credit from Chase
Ohio Home Equity Loan or Line of Credit from Chase: Great loan rates. Make home improvements, pay for college education, consolidate high-interest bills and more.

Ohio Home Equity Loans & HELOCs from Charter One
A fixed rate home equity loan in Ohio or HELOC can help you keep your house up. With Ohio home equity loans & home equity lines of credit from Charter ...

Ohio Home Equity Loans - Huntington Bank
Use the equity in your Ohio home to finance your needs. Visit Huntington today to submit a home equity loan application.

Ohio Mortgage
by Reza_0o0 ...

Home Equity Loans - Ohio, Indiana, West Virginia, and Michigan
Huntington Bank provides low-interest Home Equity Loans throughout Ohio, Indiana, West Virginia, & Michigan. Take advantage of flexible loan options ...